Joyce dissects the new KPR system – Witsup.com

A couple of weeks or so back Ironman announced that they were making some adjustments to the points qualification system for the Ironman World Championships.  The changes or in some cases, non-changes, have been received with mixed reviews. Professional triathlete, Rachel Joyce weighs in on the subject.

In general I think that the changes are an improvement although I do share some of the concerns that have already been raised in the social media world. Here I have a look at what’s changed, what hasn’t and what this means in practise for the women pro triathletes out there trying to qualify for Kona.

 

Kona goes up to 8,000 points

Previously Kona was 6,000 points: the highest scoring Ironman of the year. The points have been upped again to 8,000.  The points system have always been weighted to preference those who perform well in Kona. Increasing the points for Kona now almost guarantees the top ten finishers their place at Kona the next year so long as they have validate with a half decent Ironman and thrown a 70.3 into their schedule.  This is more in line with the pre points qualification days where a top ten finish booked your ticket to Kona the next year.

 

I think this is a good move.  If someone performs well on the world stage, racing the best in the world it’s a good thing to have that person back in the World Champs the following year.  BUT.  And it’s a big BUT this makes Kona a bit of a “closed shop” for women.  I say women because the WTC has decided to keep the women’s field at Kona to 35 versus 50 for the pro men. If we assume that the top 10 in Kona will in all probability get there again the following year, that means there are only 25 other spots open for the following year whereas men still have another 40 spots up for grab.

 

I think this is reason enough to up the women’s field in Kona to 50.  Any woman not racing in Kona in 2013, whether that be because they are out with injury, because they are an up and coming athlete or because they have just moved up to long course, will face an uphill battle to get there in 2014. I want see the likes of Julie Dibens and Cat Morrison  back in Kona. I also want to see new names shine on the world stage.   I am pretty sure the sport wants to see this too. But, is it possible to see these athletes in Kona and for them to be fresh and ready to contend for the win?  If women are forced to race two high scoring Ironmans and several 70.3 in the course of the year is that a real prospect?

 

No more 1,000 point Ironman races 

There will now be three tiers of Ironman race:2,000, 4,000 and 8,000 points.  On the surface this is good.  An Ironman is hard, it takes a lot out of you and a 1,000 is a meagre points reward for a tough days work.  The points have gone up, the prize money hasn’t.  As some have pointed out:  you can’t eat points.  A couple of years ago my heart won over economics and I race Ironman Lanzarote.  In the end (after tax deducted etc) I got less than $4,000 for the win.  My win there meant a lot but I decided that was the last Ironman I would do with the lowest prize money.  Financially it just does not make sense.  It would have been nice to see the prize money go up too.

 

I have a few questions about the change in points and not prize money:  Will athletes who can afford to race a lower paying Ironman pick up 2,000 points in a weaker field?  With the ever growing number of Ironman races on the circuit are we just going to see a further dilution of the fields?  Diluted races are not good for the professional sport.Tight, competitive racing is.  Is it time for the WTC to streamline the professional circuit so that only selected races each year have a professional race.  These races can rotate year on year but at least then we will see real races rather than individual time trials.

 

Change in weighting of points 

I was happy to see that the weighting of points for Ironman races change.  The adjusted points system looks to reward performance over racing a large number of Ironmans.  For instance, if I use Ironman Frankfurt as an example:  the woman finishing in 7th place scored 2080.  That is more points than a win in many Ironman races.  Is that right?  The current system should mean that a few top performances will secure Kona qualification over a larger number of mediocre performances. 

 

Still only 35 Kona spots for women 

I touched on disparity between the men and women’s field above.  Lots of arguments are made that 35 is proportional to the total number of registered women professionals.  I think this argument is flawed for a number of reasons:

  • There is no qualification standard for racing as a professional on the Ironman circuit.  This means there is a huge difference between the professionals finishing at the front and the back of the race in both fields.  Therefore, I don’t think it really makes much sense to rely on simple percentages of total registered professionals.  Look at the points collected by the number 50 man (3235) versus the number 50 woman (3060).  Not really that different.
  • Equality.  I think that says it all.  We count for half of the world’s population.  We should want to see triathlon be an equal sport in future generations.  What message are we sending out to kids taking up the sport with this disparity?
  • Why not? Having 15 more professional women on the start line effects no one.
  • Women’s racing has the depth to justify the top 50 women being there.  This year in Frankfurt the top 10 women were divided by 20 minutes.  The men? 19 minutes.  We have upped our game and arguments about weak fields and lack of depth are now outdated.

 

Points to debate for the future 

  • Should we see the number of qualifying Ironmans reduced from 5 to say, 3?
  • Should Iron distance specialists be able to count one of their Ironman performances towards their 70.3 qualification?

 

I know I haven’t covered everything here.  I’d love to hear what everyone else thinks so we can continue to evolve our sport…

 

Text by Rachel Joyce

Photography by Delly Carr and Witsup

 

Scroll to Top