We’ve all heard the saying, ‘You’re only cheating yourself,’ but this couldn’t be further from the truth when it comes to cheating in races – no one wins the cheating game. So we decided to speak with 2014 World Long Distance Runner Up, Vicki Hill, who was directly affected by cheating, and thankfully as of just days ago, can officially call herself the 2014 World Long Distance champion.
Interview by Matilda Raynolds | Lead image by Witsup
Sport lets us believe in the impossible, it inspires us, motivates us, gives us a distraction from ‘real life’ challenges and issues happening in the world. Most of all sport is unpredictable entertainment, as the playwright Neil Simon said, ‘Sports is the only entertainment where, no matter how many times you go back, you never know the ending.’ However, since the beginning, sport has had to challenge those who try to control that ending, to erase the uncertainty and act unfairly in order to gain an advantage or put simply – cheat!
It is an issue that is at the forefront of triathlon and has the ability to take the integrity sport to its knees similar to cycling years ago. And whilst drugs in cycling has been widely deliberated upon, its presence in triathlon is relatively new, or maybe the technology is finally been put in place to detect it more regularly. Of note, recently motors used on bikes has been identified as a potential threat that officials are trying to combat. Ironman announced they will be scanning bikes at particular races going into T1, and Challenge Roth also used technology to combat this issue as well. But one avenue, one that is much harder to detect, is the cutting of a course. A couple of months ago at Ironman Australia, an athlete who had qualified for Kona, was later disqualified by Ironman for not completing the entire course.
“Sports is the only entertainment where, no matter how many times you go back, you never know the ending.”
Neil Simon
Much has already been written about Canadian Julie Miller and her disqualification by Triathlon Canada for cheating in a number of recent triathlon events, and just days ago the ITU Arbitration Tribunal ruled that Miller would be banned for two years backdating to November 2015, she will be fined US$1000, will have to pay ITU US$2000 for procedural costs, and her World Champion title from China will be revoked. For more information check out the Triathlon Canada website.
But what we rarely hear is how the actions of cheaters affect those who were cheated out of their moment to shine. The story we are interested in telling is about the person who finished second to Miller at the 2014 ITU World Long Distance Championships in Weihai, Vicki Hill, who is now officially the 2014 World Champion.
This is Vicki Hill story so far …
WITSUP: Who is Vicki Hill and her triathlon achievements to date?
Vicki Hill: I am 41 years of age. British born but I have lived in Singapore for 14 years. Training in Singapore is generally a great place to train. Despite the hot and humid weather, we can train throughout the whole year and there are plenty of enthusiasts to swim, bike and run with!
For a small city there are lots of great 50m pools, mainly flat roads to cycle on and safe places to run. It lacks slightly for open water swims and rolling terrains to ride but with Thailand, Malayisa and Indonesia all a short hop away all options can be covered and kept interesting.
I am a runner at heart but several years ago I decided to give triathlon a go for something a bit different and I have been hooked ever since. I have participated in several halves, long distance and Olympics distance races in Asia, Europe and Australia.
(c) Jeff Lau | ITU Media
2014 was a successful year for me where I competed in my first Ironman 70.3 in Busselton and won my age group. That led me to representing Great Britain in the ITU World Long Distance Championships in Weihai where I placed “second” in my age category and then fourth in the 2015 event in Sweden. I continued to build in strength during last year and highlights include wins in my age group in Bintan Ironman 70.3 and in my debut full ironman (IM Malaysia). Both of these have secured me slots for the 70.3 World Championships and the World Championships in Kona, Hawaii for 2016.
So far this year I have placed second in Ironman 70.3 Putrajaya and won my age group recently in Vietnam 70.3, where I was also the fastest female age group run.
When I am not competing in triathlons and to pay for all these races in wonderful locations I am a teacher at UWCSEA, Singapore where I am the Head of Physical Education.
W: A few of those results you’ve mentioned I’m sure you’ve grappled with, and not because of your own personal effort. Tell us about your lead into the 2014 Long Course World Championships in Weihai, China?
VH: A win at Busselton 70.3 earlier in the year secured me a place in the Great Britain team to compete in this race. It was my first half and Weihai my first long distance triathlon so I entered this race unsure of what to expect but had trained hard and was in great shape.
(c) AsiaTri.com
W: On the Internet, Canadian Julie Miller officially beat you in that race. Since that result there have been a number of discrepancies with Julie’s racing result. Tell us about your knowledge of Julie before Weihai and how this race played out?
VH: This race was my first dealing with Julie Miller as I had not come across her before.
The females all went off together after the men in this race. I had not had a great swim and therefore I left T1 knowing that a lot of females were out on the bike ahead of me. The bike was three laps of 40km so even though I passed several females on the bike, it was impossible to know who was ahead. I had a pretty good bike, despite a few big hills and headed off on to the run feeling in good shape. The weather was hot, but training in Singapore I was used to the heat and knew this would be to my advantage. I felt strong on the run and just dug deep for the four laps of the run course. Again due to the nature of the course it was impossible to tell who was ahead of you. So I just focused on my own race, making the most of the aid stations and keeping a steady pace. I was certainly overtaking many women and no one was close to overtaking me. I spotted several Canadian females but was never aware there was a female in my age group ahead of me.
I headed to the finish feeling fairly confident I was high up the pack. On my last lap I had spotted a couple of females ahead who I felt I was catching but I had no idea what lap they were on or if they were even in my age group. On crossing the line I was told I was in first place but ahead of me another girl in my age group (Julie) had crossed the line. She was in discussion with officials saying that she was first and I agreed, after all she had crossed the line in front of me. It certainly did not cross my mind that any athlete would have cut the course!
“I had several people contacting me wanting to know if there had been anything strange about the result in Weihai.”
Vicki Hill
The results were a debacle, it took ages for them to do our awards ceremony and then it transpired that her chip had been lost/something went wrong with it. I had no reason to think otherwise and finally she was awarded first place and myself second. When the results finally came out on the website, it showed that she had come off the bike after me and then ran a faster time than me. I always knew this was wrong, as I know for a fact no girl passed me on the run. The run is my strength and no age group girl has ever passed me on the run in any race so I would be well aware of someone passing me. The results were published well after the race and I never challenged it. In hindsight, of course I should have done but I just assumed she had come off the bike well in front of me and that I could not quite get her on the run.
W: Since that race Julie has been disqualified in three separate triathlon races including both 2013 and 2015 Ironman Canada, where it was discovered she did not complete the entire run course and her result at the 2014 Vancouver Triathlon was annulled after discrepancies in her bike splits, and it’s now been made official and she has a two year ban etc. Since finding out these decisions were you able to investigate into your results from Weihai?
VH: Initially I was totally unaware that Julie had these discrepancies in her races until I was contacted by the husband of one of the girls she had cheated against in Ironman Canada. After that the story became more public, I had several people contacting me wanting to know if there had been anything strange about the result in Weihai, which again got me thinking.
I should also mention that in the 2015 ITU long course in Sweden, a few months before she was disqualified in Ironman Canada, Julie was in the race and I past her about one kilometre into the bike. I finished in fourth place and she finished well down the pack, well after me, and her run was nothing of the time she had supposedly run in Weihai. It did make me again wonder what had gone on in Weihai.
W: Do you have any theories on how Julie may have been potentially cutting the course?
VH: Not really but having read through lots of evidence from other athletes in the Canadian team of that race, it appears she somehow ducked out of a lap on the bike. Possibly she did on the run too which could explain why I had not clocked her!
“I have not really let it bother me – I have bigger things in the future to train for and focus on.”
Vicki Hill
W: Have you ever tried to reach out to Julie or speak with her at other races?
VH: No … I only saw her again at the ITU long course in Sweden and although I was slightly suspicious of her result at this stage none of the other allegations had come out. Our paths did not cross to speak with each other in Sweden.
W: If you were to cross paths with Julie what would do you wish you could say to her?
VH: Good question … I am not sure I would have any interest in speaking to her to be honest! Possibly to ask her what she really thinks she is achieving by cheating!
(c) Janos M Schmidt | ITU Media
W: How did coming second and the feeling like you may have been cheated out of a Long Course Championship title affect your training, racing and continuation in the sport?
VH: I was delighted to have come second. At the time I didn’t really think she had cheated. People put the idea in my head but I could not really believe an athlete would do that so I just put it down to her splits had been muddled up but that she had actually completed the whole course faster than me.
It was about a year after the race that this has all come to light so I have not really let it bother me – I have bigger things in the future to train for and focus on.
W: Do you think cheating in triathlon age group ranks is common?
VH: I would like to be able to say no I don’t think it is common, but I am hearing more and more stories.
W: What do you think drives an age grouper to potentially cheat where money, sponsorship and fame aren’t necessarily involved?
VH: I really have no idea. I just put it down to these people being mentally unhealthy!
Wishing Vicki Hill a massive good luck with her training, future goals, and her tilt at both the Ironman and Ironman 70.3 World Champs this year. May she receive that first place she deserves!