Menstruation And Contraception Survey by Angela Naeth – Witsup.com

Recently middle distance star Angela Naeth found herself wanting more information about what how other athletic females cope with and manage their menstruation cycle and their favored birth control method. And when goggle was giving her far to basic information and not specific to athletic women, she asked for help. Naeth put together a survey advertised it on her Facebook page and 200 athletes responded. I recently read Naeth’s breakdown of her results and thought it was interesting reading. A massive thanks for Angela for not only doing the survey, but collating the data and now sharing.

A few weeks ago I sent out a Survey with a few questions to gain information from athletic women (specifically triathletes) about their current menstruation, mode of birth control (if any), and their current symptoms. The survey was advertised on my Facebook (personal and professional), Twitter, and I sent out a few emails to fellow professional and age-group triathletes. It was simple: a handful of questions asking women about their current situation (use of hormonal therapy or not) with areas to comment on their symptoms, changes in the last 5 years, etc. In retrospect, the survey was way too short and I have way to many follow-up questions! However, the information I gathered is interesting. 200 athletes responded.

But first, why did I do this?

I’ve been in athletics since I can remember. I was an active child, had a late menarche, and never really thought much about my period until my early 20s. I was put on birth control pill (BCP) because of amenorrhea at one point, hated it (bloating etc.) and went off it. My short stint on BCP left me believing it was the devil and ‘au natural’ is/was the way to go. I finally became regular after a year or two without one. For the last 8-10 years, my cycle has been relatively on point but with devastating hiccups each month (that I chalk up to ‘woman-hood’). But I finally hit my last reserve. It was/is time to look at different options. And I wanted to find some real hard data on the subject.

The internet for such things is a scary place – I quickly found that there really is no good data and/or scientific studies (that I could find) for athletic women on their symptoms, current use of birth control and the side effects they may/may not have. There were a number of forums open to all women but those didn’t provide me anything that I felt helpful in the least (most women comment when things go bad and they are most likely not athletes). With this survey, I was hoping to find women – like me, who do triathlon that would provide some real insight. Sure, there was the chance I’d have random people answer the survey, but I’m certain I scored on the individuals I was hoping to ask (minus one – I think it was my husband. The answers were quite peculiar, and to me, it was definitely a guy!).

Before I go any further, here’s a quick run down on the menstrual cycle (I’ll keep it short!). The first day of the cycle is the first day of menses. During the first half of the menstrual cycle the pituitary gland at the base of the brain stimulates development of an egg (follicular development) and estrogen production by the ovarian. By day 14 or 15, ovulation begins (release of the egg) when the ovary produces progesterone to ready the uterine lining for implantation of the early-fertilized egg. The portion of the menstrual cycle after ovulation is called the luteal phase and normally lasts two weeks. Many women have pre-menstrual symptoms (PMS) during this time that can be minor to more severe (symptoms including but not limited to: mood swings, fatigue, headache, bloating, nausea, back-aches, breast tenderness…the list goes on). Most of us are well aware of these! And these are the symptoms (as well as those during menstruation) I refer to in the results below.

Below you’ll find the survey and responses. I didn’t include all the comments but went over them and put the ones that were common. If there were some interesting ones I added those as well.

Q1: What type of athlete are you?

76% Triathletes – Age group

18% Triathletes – Professional

7% Other – runner/cyclist

Q2: How old are you? (199 answered)

1% 20 years and younger

21% 21-29 years

60% 30-39 years

18% 40+ years

Q3: Do you currently have any symptoms/issues with your menstruation?

121 individuals answered NO

75 individuals answered YES with the following comments: (comments italicized were provided more than once)

No therapy:

Light periods

Irregular

Amenorrhea

General lethargy, hot sweats at night

Increased IBS symptoms, feeling awful

Bad cramps, endometriosis

Headaches

Back pain

Diarrhea

Heavy menstrual periods

Birth Control Pill:

Amenorrhea

Moodiness

Irregularity

Cramps

Lower back pain

IUD copper:

Pain 2-3 days monthly

Amenorrhea (no period)

Endometriosis

IUD hormonal:

Mood swings

Fatigue, dizziness

Other (Nuvaring etc):

Some spotting between

Amenorrhea

Q4: Are you currently using any birth control method? (5 skipped)

63% YES

37% NO

Q5: If yes, what are you currently on: (16 skipped)

(# of people)

68 Birth Control Pill

28 IUD hormonal

11 IUD copper

56 Do not use

Other (21): tubule litigation. Depo-Provera, nuvaring, condoms, pregnancy.

Q6: How long have you been on your current form of birth control? (50 skipped)

14% less than a year

23% 1-3 years

17% 4-5 years

46% 5+ years

Q7: In the last 5 years have you made changes to your current form/type of birth control and why? (click yes or no, please explain). (16 skipped) (Comments italicised were provided more than once)

45% Yes

55% No

Comments:

Wanted to get off hormones Pregnancy

Making me stressed/angry

Increased Blood clot risk (BCP)

Changed to IUD – forgetting to take pills

Switch from pill to Nuvaring

No therapy – husband had vasectomy

Different BCP – all causing issues

Blood clot – got off BCP

Q8: What are your symptoms currently with your form of birth control?

(30 skipped)

72% No Symptoms

38% Symptoms comments:

Similar to above: irregularity, cramps, headaches

Q9: If using oral contraceptive – which type? (65 skipped)

18% Monophasic

8% Biphasic

8% Triphasic

4% Mini-pill

62% Not applicable

Q10: Please provide any other comments, concerns, notes that would be helpful for others in regards to birth control.

  • LOVE the IUD- such an easy solution and less/no hormone.
  • Worried about blood clots on BCP
  • In race season I don’t get my period. In off-season I actively try to promote it’s cycle. Generally inactivity and weight gain helps BCP
  • I would advise women to be cautious and choose the best option for them-not based on friend consensus. Also, 10 yrs. w/o cycle does a number on your body.
  • The IUD, while painful to insert, has been an absolute life changer. I have infrequent, extremely light, and short periods (think 2-3 days) and don’t have to think about it except for once every 4-5 years.
  • I am concerned about blood clots with the Nuvaring.
  • Thanks to doing this. I’ve really struggled with balancing menstrual cycles and triathlon and it’s not a topic that’s often discussed, so I’m looking forward to your article!
  • I love the copper IUD. BCP didn’t agree with me, injection made me fat. IUD whilst I have more painful periods is much preferred. I have the first one for 10 years and had a new one put in last year which lasts for another 9. My husband and I don’t want kids so it is perfect birth control for us.
  • BCP – It is evil.
  • I’m very interested to hear if other athletes feel that birth control pill or IUD hormones impact performance. For me, it is significant enough not to use them anymore
  • I’ve been on birth control for so many years, I don’t even know what my period would be like of I wasn’t on it.
  • Took birth control pills for about 1 yr and they made me incredibly sick – affected racing, so went off them.
  • Had issues with Mirena around weight gain and stomach issues
  • No menstruation with the IUD – a common, but very welcome side-effect. I had it inserted approximately 9 years ago, and November last year “renewed my subscription”. Needs replacement every 5 years. I have had the IUD since starting triathlon so cannot even begin to imagine what it must be like to have to deal with menses or plan for it, particularly on race day. It’s the best thing I have ever done
  • Never had any problem with this pill I’m 41 and been on since 18 same one
  • If I’m off on taking it at the same time every day (forget or other) I will get bleeding and cramps
  • Thanks for researching! I hope this is helpful.
  • I tried taking the ocp 10yrs ago but was very moody and tired all the time. I then got a copper
  • IUD which was great apart from more crampy periods.
  • Noticed during my intense training that my periods are heavier
  • I’ve been on the pill for a long time (I’m 44 and don’t want kids) and for about the last 12 years, I’ve skipped the placebo week and just continued taking the active pills so I don’t menstruate. This has improved my quality of life immensely.
  • It can take a while to find what works for you.
  • I used the pill for years- numerous different ones. I found I couldn’t control my HR in hit conditions. It elevated my HR and I couldn’t get it done. When I stopped taking it, my HR normalised
  • Over 5 years ago I was on a birth control pill but still only menstruated the same as I do now- once or twice a year
  • BCP is not a good choice for female athletes, in my opinion. A woman is better off learning the rhythm of her own cycle/hormones as well as using her cycle as a look into her overall reproductive health. Also, BCP is not a solution to many of the problems female athletes can have. For example, an athlete who does not get a period, should not take BCP to get a period – all that does is mask the problem without seeking a solution and give the athlete a false sense of security that the problem has been solved while other underlying issues (eating disorders, hypogonadotropic hypogonadotropism) may be creating the problem in the first place and need attention.
  • I love Mirena IUD. I’ve been on it for 8 years and never had issues. I had cramps for the first month of so but after that it’s been fine (more than fine– no period!)
  • I had very severe energy issues and could not tolerate altitude when on the pill.
  • I haven’t menstruated since starting training for triathlons so if I had been at an age to want to have children, I’d have to stop training first before getting my cycle back to normal.
  • Mirena is very easy to use since once it is in you do not have to worry too much. But putting it in caused me vomiting which I was not prepared for. I will be interested to see how I handle removal.
  • What is particularly concerning with birth control is that all the different providers I’ve seen over the years did not warn me about estrogen based birth control and the increased risk of blood clots. Blood clots kill and I’m lucky to be alive. Shouldn’t doctors be warning their patients about the risks?
  • As an athlete having not to worry with menstruation issues is a huge plus.
  • Do not menstruate between 3 month continuous cycles during most of the year, but tend to have a period in the winter months despite continuing on pill (not falling at end of a cycle but sometime throughout a 3 month cycle).
  • Where is the men’s pill??
  • The Meridia IUD has been amazing for my training (and family control-already have three beauties!)-I don’t have any periods, no cramping, no forgetting about ‘taking’ it, and I don’t even realise it is there. Good luck with your study!
  • In the past, I have used a few types of oral contraception, but I did not like the side effects. About 6 years ago I switched to the Mirina coil. I now don’t have any periods and absolutely no side effects.
  • IUDS are rad for athletes. No pills, no patches, nothing to worry about, and they are 99.9% effective. It hurt pretty badly to be inserted and I had to fight for the copper one since I’ve never had children, but the thoughts on that are changing and I will have one put in after I have children for sure.
  • Continual birth control with no periods eliminated all ups and downs and hormonal shifts bloating and other period related issues. Made life simple.
  • I did not feel good on the pill at all so I use condoms only.
  • IUD is great but that’s because I already had kids. It could effect the ability of having kids in the future if you wanted them.
  • I used about 6 different types of birth control pill before I found one that I felt good all month on. Once you find the one that works best for you, stay with it.
  • I have zero complaints about my IUD. it was painful during the procedure and felt like normal me steal cramps for a few days after. Other then that zero problems.

Some trends that I found were:

1) More professional women were ammenhoriec than age-group (looking at numbers as well as percentages).

2) More complaints (PMS issues) for individuals on birth control pill and those not using any form of contraception.

3) Women who had the IUD hormonal provided least complaints.

After analyzing the results, I realize that this is just a small snippet into the trends of athletes and menstruation. One question (among many others) I should have asked:

1. Are you currently happy with your cycle/symptoms?

I’m assuming those that are sticking to their form of birth control or lack thereof for more than 5 years are. But, if I answered this survey (which I did), my answer would be an outright, NO. I think this is key for any further understanding of the trends that I found.

In conclusion, I hope this blog provides a little insight to those reading. I would highly recommend any woman to seek out a physician’s (specifically a gynecologist) advice for further information on this subject.

I want to thank those that took the time do fill out the survey. I may do another one asking more questions on performance in training/races and ask what individuals found helpful in decreasing some of the symptoms they deal with on a monthly basis. If you have specific questions you’d like to see answered, please message me!

I do have to say, after reading the responses, us women, we are a one, complicated bunch. 🙂

Follow Angela Online

Scroll to Top